Lessons Learned: The Journey of Thermal Cycling and Damascus Steel

Lessons Learned: The Journey of Thermal Cycling and Damascus Steel


In the ever-evolving world of knife making, there's always room for experimentation and learning. As a custom knife maker from Winneg, Manitoba, I recently encountered an unexpected challenge that led to valuable insights and lessons. Join me as I recount my experience with thermal cycling, damascus steel, and the discoveries that continue to shape my craft.

The Forge Upgrade:

In my pursuit of improving my forging process, I made a significant change by upgrading the blower on my forge. This alteration resulted in higher temperatures, which initially seemed advantageous. However, I soon realized that the increased heat had unintended consequences for my beautiful random pattern damascus steel.

The Unfortunate Overheating:

During the forging process, I unintentionally overheated the damascus steel due to the higher temperatures generated by the new blower. This error became apparent when I conducted an acid etch, revealing imperfections and damage in the steel. Disheartened but determined, I embarked on a journey to rectify the situation.

Insufficient Thermal Cycling:

Upon reflection, I discovered that my previous thermal cycling routine was insufficient to address the damage caused by the overheating. In response, I decided to implement a more rigorous approach. I conducted a total of seven rounds of thermal cycling, including a DET (Differential Thermal Etching) anneal, to gradually improve the steel's properties.

damascus steel

The Benefits of Thermal Cycling:

The intensive thermal cycling process proved invaluable. Not only did it increase the toughness of the steel, but it also refined the grain structure, resulting in a superior quality material. Armed with this newfound knowledge, I'm now eager to put the finishing touches on these revitalized knives.

Handles and Sales:

With the steel restored and improved, the next step in this journey is fitting the knives with carefully crafted handles. Each knife, born from this challenging experience, will be a testament to the resilience of both the steel and the maker. I'm excited to offer these unique pieces for sale, allowing others to appreciate the craftsmanship that emerged from this transformative process.

The Power of Knowledge:

Throughout this entire experience, one resource proved invaluable: Dr. Larrin Thomas' book "Knife Engineering" (also known as "Knifesteel Nerds"). Through reading and studying this comprehensive guide, I gained a deeper understanding of the technical aspects of knife making. It empowered me to navigate and overcome the obstacles encountered during this journey.

Reflection and Moving Forward:

While the experimentation with thermal cycling and the recovery of the damascus steel proved largely successful, I must admit that the experience was arduous. Although I am glad to have learned more about the process of normalization and the resilience of the steel, if given the chance to redo this situation, I would likely choose to start from scratch instead. The lessons learned have solidified my respect for the delicate balance of the forging process and the importance of meticulous temperature control.


Every challenge is an opportunity for growth and learning. My encounter with overheating and subsequent thermal cycling not only refined my craft but also reinforced the importance of continuous education in the field of knife making. With the lessons learned and the blades now ready for sale, I eagerly anticipate sharing these unique creations with knife enthusiasts who appreciate the artistry and resilience that emerges from the forge.

Remember, every setback can be a stepping stone toward greater expertise. Stay curious, keep exploring, and embrace the journey of constant improvement in your craft.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.